I really liked the scene of this perfume and so just based on that alone, it gets 4 stars. The silage and longevity aren't the strongest but at this price point, I think it's about average. I'm not keen on the bottle design though. Not a deal breaker at all, just find it a bit clunky and not the prettiest bottle on a dresser. Ultimately, the bottle doesn't matter much but perfume is one of the few products that I actually like the bottle to be a bit more high end looking.